Squad Stats Comparison - TA specific - Tartan Army Message Board Jump to content

Squad Stats Comparison


Caledonian Craig

Recommended Posts

With Euro 2020 almost upon us I have compiled some stats on the nine Scotland squads to compete in major tournaments. The stats show that squad's average age, average caps won per player and average goals per player. Obviously, the 2020 squad will improve its stats as it has yet to play two friendlies before Euro 2020.

TOURNAMENT                    Average Age              Average Caps         Average Goals        Major Tournaments Experience

2020                                       26.76                            16.84                         1.26                                  0.00

1998                                       29.22                            23.00                        2.00                                  1.04

1996                                       29.31                             23.31                        2.36                                  0.90

1992                                       27.15                              19.15                         1.75                                   0.70

1990                                       27.00                             20.90                        1.77                                   0.45

1986                                       27.09                             21.90                        1.59                                    0.50

1982                                       26.90                            22.86                        2.54                                   0.40

1978                                       27.40                             19.09                        2.59                                   0.27

1974                                       25.72                             13.95                        2.36                                   0.00

 

The stand-out squad on paper had to be the 1974 World Cup squad. It was laced with several players who are recognised as Scotland legends such as McGrain, Bremner, Jimmy Johnstone, Dalglish, Jordan, Lorimer and Law. Surprising it was the most experienced squad to be sent to a major tournament by Scotland but then when you think about it there were less international matches played to qualify so less caps on offer. It was also the youngest squad to play in a major tournament too even beating our current squad. The glaring and not unexpected stat our current squad is a lack of goals in it. I hope that doesn't come back to bite us.

The major tournaments stat is worked out on how many major tournaments each player in the squad had played in prior to the tournament.

The current squad does have a claim to fame over all the previous squads in that Nathan Patterson and Billy Gilmour are the first teenagers named in any Scotland squad for a major tournament.

I hope you enjoy the stats. All a bit of fun.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Always think is a bit unfair to compare squads. Some of the players in 74 in were past their prime and others hadn't reached theirs. If all those players were at their prime in 74 we might have won it.

We might be looking back in 30 years thinking we had a great squad this time round but we would be basing it on Gordon being a great keeper(which he was), Gilmour and Patterson and Turnbull  being great internationalists which they aren't yet,and Tierney being world class without taking into account he was playing out of position.

I do like the average age though I think players are at their peak from 23-27 which a lot of ours are. Truly great players can start this peak sooner and make it last longer maybe Tierney and the newbies can.

Hopefully we will have the core of this this squad in Qatar and the average number of caps per player will be over 25 Although average caps  is more interesting when it comes down to players who actually play

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, breeks_mctavish said:

Great stats Craig, thanks for sharing. The average goals is quite frightening! Hopefully it's just a reflection of the years of underachievement of the recent past rather than an indicator of what to expect moving forwards!

You would think with the San Marinos's and the likes about now our goals average would be far better these days than it was years ago.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, ceudmilefailte said:

Always think is a bit unfair to compare squads. Some of the players in 74 in were past their prime and others hadn't reached theirs. If all those players were at their prime in 74 we might have won it.

 

 

There was a good blend in the 74 squad. Sure you had players in their 30s such as Bremner and Law but there was a strong batch of youngsters destined for great things such as Dalglish (23), Jordan (22) and McGrain (24). The odd thing was it had potent strikers yet we crashed out by not scoring enough goals against Zaire and failing to beat Yugoslavia.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Caledonian Craig said:

There was a good blend in the 74 squad. Sure you had players in their 30s such as Bremner and Law but there was a strong batch of youngsters destined for great things such as Dalglish (23), Jordan (22) and McGrain (24). The odd thing was it had potent strikers yet we crashed out by not scoring enough goals against Zaire and failing to beat Yugoslavia.

 

Pity we were so sure we would bet Yugoslavia.....................

And we hadn't beaten Brazil...........................

Edited by ceudmilefailte
Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, ceudmilefailte said:

Always think is a bit unfair to compare squads. Some of the players in 74 in were past their prime and others hadn't reached theirs. If all those players were at their prime in 74 we might have won it.

We might be looking back in 30 years thinking we had a great squad this time round but we would be basing it on Gordon being a great keeper(which he was), Gilmour and Patterson and Turnbull  being great internationalists which they aren't yet,and Tierney being world class without taking into account he was playing out of position.

I do like the average age though I think players are at their peak from 23-27 which a lot of ours are. Truly great players can start this peak sooner and make it last longer maybe Tierney and the newbies can.

Hopefully we will have the core of this this squad in Qatar and the average number of caps per player will be over 25 Although average caps  is more interesting when it comes down to players who actually play

 

 

That's a very good point. It's always far more nuanced. A good example might be looking at our squad circa 2003. On paper, it looks good based off their careers. But the likes of Darren Fletcher, James McFadden and Shaun Maloney were teenagers at that point. Kenny Miller and Craig Gordon were youngsters as well. Where as the likes of Paul Lambert and David Weir were nearing retirement. We had pretty much no one at their peak at that point, barring maybe Barry Ferguson and Jackie MacNamara, but we actually had decent international players around the squad in that period.

Our current team aren't peaking yet. Far from it. But half a dozen will possibly peak around the same time in a few years, having spent years playing together.

Edited by Tartan blood
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its more about balance in my opinion. You can have a squad with not the most caps but with more talent say, than one with more experience throughout. Perfect balance would be experience through the spine of the team - in goal, central defence, centre of midfield and up front with a lot of young players too whose best is yet to come. So a mix of experience and young talent is the ideal blend.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

With Scotland's current squad having played their pre-tournament friendlies picking up more caps and goals the stats of this squad now looks like this:-

 

TOURNAMENT                    Average Age              Average Caps         Average Goals        Major Tournaments                                                                                                                                                                         Experience

2020                                       26.84                            18.53                         1.38                                  0.00

1998                                       29.22                            23.00                        2.00                                  1.04

1996                                       29.31                             23.31                        2.36                                  0.90

1992                                       27.15                              19.15                         1.75                                   0.70

1990                                       27.00                             20.90                        1.77                                   0.45

1986                                       27.09                             21.90                        1.59                                    0.50

1982                                       26.90                            22.86                        2.54                                   0.40

1978                                       27.40                             19.09                        2.59                                   0.27

1974                                       25.72                             13.95                        2.36                                   0.00

Edited by Caledonian Craig
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...


×
×
  • Create New...