aaid's Content - Page 7 - Tartan Army Message Board Jump to content

aaid

Member
  • Posts

    13,230
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    47

Posts posted by aaid

  1. 17 minutes ago, Orraloon said:

    He was, but I meant he wasn't that great for Scotland. Decent but not great. He would walk into the team we have now, though. 

    I was talking about in comparison to McBurnie who is neither.  

  2. 1 hour ago, Orraloon said:

    Is it not being paid for by borrowing? Does Scotland not fund a share of that borrowing? Or, are we getting a "refund" every year under Barnett until the debt is paid off? Which will be never.

    Barnett consequentials work this way.

    Lets say a project in England costs £1billion over 10 years and is subject to Barnett in Scotland, then over that 10 year period Scotland will get £117 million  - 2019 numbers - added to that budget over that 10 year period.   The Scottish Government decides what it wants to spend that money on.

    The UK Treasury to fund that £1billion project needs to raise £1.117 billion, usually through borrowing and needs to pay that debt back over time.   

    So we get additional money, decide what we spend it on, and then have to pay back the money that was borrowed to give to us.   

  3. On 10/19/2023 at 8:50 PM, stocky said:

    We do produce good strikers, however they tend to be allergic to playing for Scotland for one reason or another...

    This century, all top finishers..

    Duncan Ferguson

    Kris Boyd

    Jordan Rhodes

    Gary o Connor

    Leigh Griffiths

    Steven Fletcher

    Ross Macormack

    Derek Riordan

    I'm sure there are more,

    Most if not all of these guys if they had, had Kenny Miller's commitment or circumstances had been different could easy have scored 20+ for Scotland.

    However we have never really had top scoring strikers for some reason, even Lyndon Dykes has more than Joe Jordan.  

    None of these guys are “top finishers”.

    They fall into two categories, flat track bullies - Boyd, Rhodes, McCormack - or guys with poorer than average scoring records - Ferguson (1 in 3.6), Fletcher (1 in 4).

    A third category, ex Hibs Neds - Griffiths, O’Connor, Riordan. 

  4. On 10/19/2023 at 4:27 PM, daviebee said:

    McCoist - 19 in 61; Johnston - 14 in 38.

    No idea if you ever seen Johnston at his peak, but Steve Clarke would skin a kitten alive in the centre circle of a sold-out Hampden to have a striker of that quality available to him.  He was a brilliant player, especially when he moved to Nantes.  His game went up several levels.  I hope we find somebody better than him as well cos we'll have one hell of a player if we do.

    I absolutely loved McCoist as a player, my favourite ever player, but I think Johnston is the last exceptional striker that we’ve had. A striker that if he were playing you’d expect to score.

  5. 1 hour ago, Dave78 said:

     

    So we end up having 3 pro-indy parties in holyrood. The radical/hard left of the Greens, radical/hard right of Alba, and the centrist managerial soft-left of the SNP.

    I don’t see where you get this view of Alba as a radical hard right party.  Their economic view is pretty much left wing or at least those who seem to be driving their economic policies are, ie, George Kerevan.  They differ from the Greens as they don’t tend to care much about the environment and their model seems to be about central rather than local control.  They remind me a lot of sections of 1980s Labour complete with the small ‘c’ conservatism.

  6. 15 minutes ago, Hertsscot said:

    Thank you for pointing that out. I had a look this morning and I couldn't find any mention of it at all. I did a rough calculation so guessed the turnout wasn't great but it's nice to have actual figures. Obviously such low turnouts make any future predictions a bit more unpredictable.

    This tweet shows that when comparing the turnout to a poll carried out in the constituency on voting intention, that turnout across the board is down.  It’s not just a case of the Tory vote stayed at home and the Labour vote turned out.   A great deal of traditional Tory voters must have voted Labour.

    https://x.com/damiansurvation/status/1715329517575651836?s=61&t=MHJIOYAKuUpVTHulpYS2rQ

  7. 18 minutes ago, Ally Bongo said:

    Once again the BBC are loathed to mention that turnout in both by-elections was well down

    Tamworth went from 64% to 35% and the Labour vote was up by only 800 from 2019

    Mid Bedfordshire went from 73% to 44% and the Labour vote was down from 2019

    They would rather spout pish about British Labour being unstoppable

    So what you’re saying is that the reaction to Rutherglen and Hamilton West was overcooked by the media?   

×
×
  • Create New...