The news thread - Page 4 - Anything Goes - Other topics not covered elsewhere - Tartan Army Message Board Jump to content

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, aaid said:

You don’t think victims of rape and sexual assault should not be entitled to anonymity?

Are you happy with the atrociously low level of convictions in these cases.

What do you think? Yeah, I’m pure delighted. 🙄

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 93
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

13 minutes ago, duncan II said:

What do you think? Yeah, I’m pure delighted. 🙄

And equally (yes, equally) should an accused not be allowed anonymity until convicted? What if he’s innocent? Anyway, this is going down a road I don’t want to go. I fully support victims in such cases. Just thought there was hypocrisy that needed calling out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, vanderark14 said:

Simone Biles withdrawing from another event in the Olympics to protect her mental health.

Piers morgan has upset a few people about this on twatter 

 

Must just be natural but as a middle aged bloke I understand current culture less and less.  Doubt Mental Dave in our old pub team would have called me brave if I subbed myself off in the Tunstall Alliance League 5 cup final for squaffing a pass five minutes in leaving us down to 10 whilst shouting platitudes and proffering oranges from the side-line. 

If she pulls out completely I’ll buy its mental health rather than just fucking it up on the first bit of apparatus and chucking toys out the pram.  Can see a Hollywood finale though where she wins the four individual titles next week and everyone hails her rise from adversity as vindication of putting herself before the team which would succinctly sum up where we are as a society.  The hypocrisy will be likely nobody will give a shit for wellbeing of the other team members who carried on to battle to a meaningless silver in terms of US sporting demands and then probably have to watch the person who cost them possibly their best shot at gold then beat them individually.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, vanderark14 said:

Simone Biles withdrawing from another event in the Olympics to protect her mental health.

Piers morgan has upset a few people about this on twatter 

 

It's always amusing when someone most famous for mendacity and then storming off his show in a huff tries to judge someone with like 2 dozen gold medals in international competition on their mental stregnth in competition.

He's the worlds foremost ultracrepidarian

Link to comment
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, ThistleWhistle said:

Must just be natural but as a middle aged bloke I understand current culture less and less.  Doubt Mental Dave in our old pub team would have called me brave if I subbed myself off in the Tunstall Alliance League 5 cup final for squaffing a pass five minutes in leaving us down to 10 whilst shouting platitudes and proffering oranges from the side-line. 

If she pulls out completely I’ll buy its mental health rather than just fucking it up on the first bit of apparatus and chucking toys out the pram.  Can see a Hollywood finale though where she wins the four individual titles next week and everyone hails her rise from adversity as vindication of putting herself before the team which would succinctly sum up where we are as a society.  The hypocrisy will be likely nobody will give a shit for wellbeing of the other team members who carried on to battle to a meaningless silver in terms of US sporting demands and then probably have to watch the person who cost them possibly their best shot at gold then beat them individually.

 

 

Wow you took that almost as personally as Morgan seems to. I read it all the way thinking it was another verbose joke but it wasn't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, phart said:

 

Wow you took that almost as personally as Morgan seems to. I read it all the way thinking it was another verbose joke but it wasn't.

It's vexed me all day being honest - Twitter is just a sewer where all that counts is who has the biggest gang numbers be it in faux outrage or sincerity.   

Guilty as charged on the verbose comment.  

       

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, ThistleWhistle said:

It's vexed me all day being honest - Twitter is just a sewer where all that counts is who has the biggest gang numbers be it in faux outrage or sincerity.   

Guilty as charged on the verbose comment.  

       

here's a technical explanation of what is going on

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, phart said:

here's a technical explanation of what is going on

 

Said before if she ends up pulling out of the whole thing then fair enough and from that it wouldn't seem you could go from the 'Twisties' one day then a few days later be seriously competing unless I'm missing something? 

  

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, ThistleWhistle said:

Said before if she ends up pulling out of the whole thing then fair enough and from that it wouldn't seem you could go from the 'Twisties' one day then a few days later be seriously competing unless I'm missing something? 

  

 

I’m no expert or anything, just a simple chap, but why does this bother you so?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, ThistleWhistle said:

Said before if she ends up pulling out of the whole thing then fair enough and from that it wouldn't seem you could go from the 'Twisties' one day then a few days later be seriously competing unless I'm missing something? 

  

 

She's withdrawn from the individual all round as well.

I have no idea how quickly kinesthesia can be repaired.

I watch combat sports and it's canon in them that you don't compete if your head isn't right. I trust the judgement of the folk in the gymnastics who don't seem surprised/outraged. I'll defer to their judgement as opposed to making bad faith judgements from my couch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, phart said:

She's withdrawn from the individual all round as well.

I have no idea how quickly kinesthesia can be repaired.

I watch combat sports and it's canon in them that you don't compete if your head isn't right. I trust the judgement of the folk in the gymnastics who don't seem surprised/outraged. I'll defer to their judgement as opposed to making bad faith judgements from my couch.

My beef isn't really with an Olympic gymnast I'll probably forget about in a month but more around the lack of nuance in everything and increasing levels of moral myopia governed by likes and retweets rather than discussion.  

Yeah I'd known about her pulling out of the all round as a few places were reporting it yesterday morning but was undecided for the weekend/ next week.  Only found out from an article on the BBC last night that she had been out for over a year and only returned April this year I think it is.  

Unfortunately Twitter's whole business model is based on bad faith decisions given in a limited number of characters and it's impact can't  be underestimated as it effectively controls the narrative/direction of society in specific moments with reflection postponed until later.   The easy answer in this is for a full on luvvie capricious spewing of platitudes whereas the more difficult question of whether their management committee has failed in its duty of care isn't being raised yet although that may well follow.

If she does compete in the individuals it opens up another can of worms in that nobody would want see her do a Ronaldo or hurt herself but if she did perform poorly then the management again would have questions to answer with her being in that position.  If on the other hand she wins gold then the fairytale Hollywood ending is there but it would still raise difficult questions.  Nobody is likely to touch the one how you can go from unable to perform due to mental health issues to gold medallist in the space of a week understandably because, although it is a pretty pertinent question in improving understanding, it would turn toxic immediately.  The other is that she would be fully vindicated in her actions given the reward but would the moral to take from the story of putting yourself first at the expense of the team be healthy particularly?  Not her load to carry but it's still an interesting question like if England are ok with Kane and Sterling to take a dive why shouldn't kids when they return to football this season?

Morgan is a knob but he does raise a valid point in that the social media hypocrisy is ridiculous and dangerous.  Nobody is really interested in his mental health when he stormed off and came back basically because he's a knob.  He's not an Olympic Goat but he is in a fairly cut-throat business that would be churlish to admit he wasn't at the top end of so maybe the weatherman exposed a vulnerability that day.  Essentially going from his feed though there's everything from poking fun at his meltdown to being fat, racist, misogynist and all the the way through to nonce.        

 

Edited by ThistleWhistle
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If she or any athlete for that matter do not want to compete because of their mental health then they should be allowed to work on their recovery. Given the abuse she suffered as a child as well. 

I can do without the social media / media virtue signalling though who go after people on a daily basis with no regard for mental health. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, ThistleWhistle said:

My beef isn't really with an Olympic gymnast I'll probably forget about in a month but more around the lack of nuance in everything and increasing levels of moral myopia governed by likes and retweets rather than discussion.  

Yeah I'd known about her pulling out of the all round as a few places were reporting it yesterday morning but was undecided for the weekend/ next week.  Only found out from an article on the BBC last night that she had been out for over a year and only returned April this year I think it is.  

Unfortunately Twitter's whole business model is based on bad faith decisions given in a limited number of characters and it's impact can't  be underestimated as it effectively controls the narrative/direction of society in specific moments with reflection postponed until later.   The easy answer in this is for a full on luvvie capricious spewing of platitudes whereas the more difficult question of whether their management committee has failed in its duty of care isn't being raised yet although that may well follow.

If she does compete in the individuals it opens up another can of worms in that nobody would want see her do a Ronaldo or hurt herself but if she did perform poorly then the management again would have questions to answer with her being in that position.  If on the other hand she wins gold then the fairytale Hollywood ending is there but it would still raise difficult questions.  Nobody is likely to touch the one how you can go from unable to perform due to mental health issues to gold medallist in the space of a week understandably because, although it is a pretty pertinent question in improving understanding, it would turn toxic immediately.  The other is that she would be fully vindicated in her actions given the reward but would the moral to take from the story of putting yourself first at the expense of the team be healthy particularly?  Not her load to carry but it's still an interesting question like if England are ok with Kane and Sterling to take a dive why shouldn't kids when they return to football this season?

Morgan is a knob but he does raise a valid point in that the social media hypocrisy is ridiculous and dangerous.  Nobody is really interested in his mental health when he stormed off and came back basically because he's a knob.  He's not an Olympic Goat but he is in a fairly cut-throat business that would be churlish to admit he wasn't at the top end of so maybe the weatherman exposed a vulnerability that day.  Essentially going from his feed though there's everything from poking fun at his meltdown to being fat, racist, misogynist and all the the way through to nonce.        

 

Piers Morgan is an utter prick who will say anything to create controversy. He lives in the British 70’s and in his time has probably created mental health issues for many people with his articles and tweets. He chooses to be in a cut throat business and if you choose to be outspoken then you need to be able to suck it up when you are on the receiving end. 

I didnt know anything about this gymnast but I can only imagine the pressure top level sports people are under these days , you are absolutely right, social media has become a beast and the hypocrisy stinks. 

I have no reason to think she is using mental health as a excuse . She is only 24 , regardless of her tough regime and high endurance levels she will still be vulnerable, and the consequences of making a mistake could be catastrophic .
But I do think social media goes overboard with its focus on mental health, which ends up diminishing the seriousness of it. 

Piers Morgan seems more concerned that she is letting down her country and her sponsors , what a surprise. 
 



 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, ParisInAKilt said:

If she or any athlete for that matter do not want to compete because of their mental health then they should be allowed to work on their recovery. Given the abuse she suffered as a child as well. 

I can do without the social media / media virtue signalling though who go after people on a daily basis with no regard for mental health. 

Don't disagree at all and it'll be interesting to see if things have moved on from France 98 where there was the stench sponsors had a part to play in Ronaldo playing when he pretty obviously wasn't fit.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share




×
×
  • Create New...